Overweight and obesity: BMI does not reflect risk of death, says study

NEWS

  07/07/2023 | Pascal Lemontel

 

 
Facebook Twitter Mail Imprimer
This article is also available in the following languages:
 

A recent study calls into question the body mass index (BMI) as a reliable indicator of health. According to the authors, people who are overweight according to BMI do not have an increased risk of death, unlike obese people. The study, published in the journal PLOS ONE, highlights the importance of other measures, such as the distribution of excess body fat, in assessing health status. Although BMI is widely used in the medical field, it is increasingly considered a limited tool.



The study analyzed data from more than 550,000 U.S. adults over a 20-year period and found that overweight people (BMI between 25 and 30) did not have an increased risk of death compared to people with a lower BMI. normal (between 22.5 and less than 25). However, the risk of death increased significantly in people with a BMI less than 20 or equal to or greater than 30 (obese).



The researchers emphasize that other factors such as measuring waist circumference, bone and muscle density must be taken into account to assess health status. Although diseases related to being overweight, such as diabetes or cardiovascular disease, remain associated with health problems, BMI alone does not provide a complete picture of a person's health.



It should also be noted that medical advances in the treatment of obesity-related illnesses may influence the relationship between weight and mortality. While some previous studies have linked being overweight to an increased risk of death, this new study suggests that the relationship between weight and mortality may change over time.



In summary, although BMI is a simple and commonly used tool, it should not be considered the only indicator of health. Other measurements and factors must be taken into account to more accurately assess a person's health status.

  Pascal Lemontel

 WE RECOMMEND YOU

  > Nutri-Score: the government validates the new version of nutritional labeling

  > Using fewer cosmetics quickly reduces the trace of pollutants in the body.

 










   
 

The young Frenchman Elio has found his bone marrow donor and will be able to receive a transplant.

 NEWS 

 

 18/05/2026

The battle of 4-year-old Elio, who suffers from a rare form of leukemia, had already captivated social media. Last night, his parents announced a decisive breakthrough on Instagram: a compatible donor ...

   
   

Ultra-processed foods: cardiologists raise the alarm

 NEWS 

 

 12/05/2026

Ultra-processed foods are taking up an increasingly large portion of our plates. Convenient and inexpensive, they are nevertheless associated with increasingly well-documented health risks. European cardiologists ...

   
   

Listeria: Contaminated shrimp recalled across France

 NEWS 

 

 11/05/2026

A batch of cooked shrimp sold at Grand Frais is being recalled nationwide due to contamination with Listeria monocytogenes, the bacterium responsible for listeriosis, according to the government's consumer ...

   
   

Gynecology: Hormonal Cycles at Every Age

sample74

▶ REPLAY

Available to listen

Ladies, as you know, your body is far more complex than a man’s, due to the frequent changes in your hormonal cycles. Shorter cycles during perimenopaus

   
   

 12/05/2026

Ultra-processed foods: cardiologists raise the alarm

Ultra-processed foods are taking up an increasingly large portion of our plates. Convenient and inexpensive, they are nevertheless associated with increasingly well-documented

 

 NEWS 

  06/05/2026

Flu: towards mandatory vaccination for healthcare workers

In France, only 20% of healthcare workers get vaccinated against the flu each year. Faced with this insufficient rate, the National Academy of Medicine now recommends making

 

 NEWS 

  04/05/2026

Hantavirus: WHO investigates at sea

The World Health Organization is investigating several cases of severe acute respiratory illness detected on board a cruise ship in the Atlantic, possibly linked to a hantavirus.

 

 SOCIAL 

  30/04/2026

France halts non-surgical FemBloc sterilization

The French National Agency for Medicines and Health Products Safety (ANSM) decided on Thursday to suspend the permanent contraception device FemBloc, concluding that the available

 

 SOCIAL 

  28/04/2026

Quality of care in France: the Court of Auditors raises the alarm

 

 TREATMENTS 

  24/04/2026

The United States approves a new treatment for deafness

 

 RESEARCH 

  22/04/2026

Using fewer cosmetics quickly reduces the trace of pollutants in the body.

 

 NEWS 

  20/04/2026

United States: Trump eases bans on psychedelic substances

 

 NEWS 

  16/04/2026

Baldness: a certificate is now mandatory to obtain finasteride



   

Contenus sponsorisés


 26/05/2025

Cardiovascular health: Improve prevention!

Cardiovascular diseases remain the leading cause of death worldwide, representing a significant public health challenge. An alarming reality A recent study by Public Hea

 

 PREVENTION 

  19/05/2025

Melanoma: Concrete Initiatives in Care

 

 PREVENTION 

  03/03/2025

Meningitis: a large-scale vaccination campaign in the Rennes metropolitan area

The Regional Health Agency (ARS) of Brittany has announced a large-scale vaccination campaign for 100,000 young people aged 15 to 24 in the Rennes metropolitan area following

 

 PREVENTION 

  04/02/2025

COPD: The importance of early diagnosis!

COPD, a chronic respiratory disease that remains largely unknown, is claiming more and more victims. Early diagnosis, a major challenge, was highlighted at the 29th French-Language

 

 PREVENTION 

  03/02/2025

Colorectal cancer: The ARC Foundation breaks the taboos!

 

 PREVENTION 

  21/01/2025

Eye problems: Take care of your eyes today!

 

 PREVENTION 

  30/12/2024

Bacterial meningitis: expanded vaccination from January 1, 2025

 

 PREVENTION 

  28/10/2024

Prostate cancer: innovative treatments and diagnostics!

 

 PREVENTION 

  16/10/2024

The air in our homes: a ticking time bomb for our health!



   


     
     






 
     
     
 
 

NOS RADIOS

 

SERVICES

 

THEMATIQUES

 

OUTILS

 

Radio Public Santé
Public Santé Seniors
Public Santé Détente
Public Santé Loisirs & Sports
Public Santé Famille
Public Santé Sexo
Public Santé Nutri-Conso
Public Health Radio
Bien-être Animal
Replay News
Replay News Eco
Replay News Story

 

Frequencies
Replay
Programs
Find
Contact us
Health news
Webradios
Seasonal Diseases

 

Beauty
Nutrition
Family
Hobbies
Prevention
Psychology
Research
Treatments
Sport
Administrative & social
Litterature
Sexology
Animal health

 

Flux RSS
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Linkedin
Newsletters
Services
Journalists
Technical
Press

 

 
 

Rights of reproduction and distribution reserved © Control Channel 2006-2026
Strictly personal use. The user of the site acknowledges having read the usage rights license,
in accept and respect its provisions.

Mentions légales | Conditions générales d'utilisation | Politique de protection des données personnelles | Politique relative aux cookies